The main drawback of most garbage collectors is the need for long application pauses. These pauses are the result of an inevitable requirement to compact the heap to free up space. Collectors use different strategies to delay these events, but compaction is inevitable for all commercial available collectors except the Azul C4 which employs a Continuously Concurrent Compacting Collector that avoids pauses altogether.
The C4 (Continuously Concurrent Compacting Collector) is an updated generational form of the Azul Pauseless GC Algorithm and is the default collector of Zing®. C4 differentiates itself from other generational garbage collectors by supporting simultaneous – generational concurrency: the different generations are collected using concurrent (non stop-the-world) mechanisms that can be simultaneously and independently active. Unlike other algorithms, it is not ‘mostly’ concurrent, but fully concurrent, so it never falls back to a stop-the-world compaction.
A summary of garbage collectors is below. For more information on the terminology and more details on the collectors, read the Understanding Java GC white paper.
|
JVM |
Collector Name |
Young Generation |
Old Generation |
|
Oracle’sHotSpot |
ParallelGC |
Monolithic, stop the world, copying |
Monolithic, stop-the-world, Mark/Sweep/Compact |
|
Oracle’sHotSpot |
CMS (Concurrent Mark/Sweep) |
Monolithic, stop the world, copying |
Mostly concurrent marker, concurrent, non-compacting sweeper, fall back to monolithic stop-the-world compaction |
|
Oracle’sHotSpot |
G1 (Garbage First) |
Monolithic, stop the world, copying |
Mostly concurrent marker, mostly incremental compaction, fall back to monolithic stop-the-world |
|
Oracle’sJRockit* |
Dynamic Garbage Collector |
Monolithic, stop-the-world, copying |
Mark/Sweep – can choose mostly concurrent or parallel, incremental compaction, fall back to monolithic stop-the-world |
|
IBM J9* |
Balanced |
Monolithic, stop-the-world, copying |
Mostly concurrent marker, mostly incremental compaction, fall back to monolithic stop-the-world |
|
IBM J9* |
optthruput |
Monolithic, stop-the-world, copying |
Parallel Mark/Sweep, stop-the-world compaction |
|
Azul Zing |
C4 (Continuously Concurrent Compacting Collector) |
Concurrent, compacting |
Concurrent, compacting |
Garbage Collection (GC) is an integral part of application behavior on Java platforms. Java developers can improve application performance, scalability and reliability by understanding how GC works and by making better garbage collector choices.
More resources:
*Note that with IBM’s J9 and Oracle’s JRockit you can choose to have a single or 2-generation garbage collector
